Bracketology: NCAA tournament projection as of March 8, 2018

  • 03/08/2018 8:03 am in

Bucknell was the only team to earn an automatic bid on Wednesday, but that certainly doesn’t mean the day was short on drama.

Teams on the outside looking in like Louisville, Oklahoma State and Notre Dame picked up key wins, while early season darlings like Arizona State and Oklahoma continued their slide toward the cut line by losing their first conference tournament games.

A quick note on the Sooners, who ended up higher than I expected in these projections. The committee has said that it doesn’t give additional weight to the last 10 games, which I am taking at face value. The reality is they have just one loss to a team not in the at-large picture, and they have five wins against the RPI Top 25 and six total quadrant 1 wins.

All of the teams mentioned above will be rooting against potential bid thieves as more conference tournaments get underway. At this point, there are three leagues that have the greatest potential to wreak havoc on the at-large picture.

Middle Tennessee finished 16-2 in Conference USA and owns a non-conference strength of schedule that ranks among the nation’s best. The Blue Raiders have a pair of quadrant 1 wins (at Murray State and at Western Kentucky) and lost their other three quadrant 1 games by six points or less. A Top 30 RPI and a 12-1 mark in true road games help their case as well, but I wouldn’t call them an at-large lock at this stage. If they lose in the C-USA final though, I find it hard to believe they’d be left out.

In the Mountain West, Nevada is the squad bubble teams should be pulling for. The Wolf Pack boast a Top 20 RPI with a Top 20 non-conference strength of schedule. Like MTSU, Nevada has two quadrant 1 wins, which came against Rhode Island at home and on the road against Boise State. They have five more victories in quadrant 2, but a pair of quadrant 3 losses will hold down their seed. Still, Nevada is poised to go dancing regardless of what they do in the MWC Tournament, which means if any other team runs the table, there will be one less spot up for grabs.

Both Rhode Island and St. Bonaventure are in my projected field, with the Rams the safer of the two A-10 schools. Like Nevada, Rhode Island ranks in the RPI Top 20 with a pair of quadrant 1 wins. They have just one bad loss and a non-conference strength of schedule among the five best in the country.

The Bonnies look relatively safe as well, although a loss in their first A-10 Tournament game could make things interesting thanks to a trio of losses in quadrants 3 and 4. Davidson feels like the only team outside of Rhode Island and St. Bonaventure that is capable of stringing together enough wins to earn the automatic bid.

Here’s a quick reminder of how the selection committee is classifying wins this season.

· Quadrant 1: Home vs. teams ranked 1-30 / Neutral vs. teams ranked 1-50 / Road vs. teams ranked 1-75
· Quadrant 2: Home vs. teams ranked 31-75 / Neutral vs. teams ranked 51-100 / Road vs. teams ranked 76-135
· Quadrant 3: Home vs. teams ranked 76-160 / Neutral vs. teams ranked 101-200 / Road vs. teams ranked 136-240
· Quadrant 4: Home vs. teams ranked 161-351 / Neutral vs. teams ranked 201-351 / Road vs. teams ranked 241-351

The Bracket

The projections below are based on all games played through March 7, 2018. Following the bracket, I included a few thoughts on the last four in and first five out.

SOUTH (ATLANTA)   EAST (BOSTON)
Charlotte – March 16/18 Pittsburgh – March 15/17
1) Virginia 1) Villanova
16) LIU Brooklyn / AR-Pine Bluff 16) SE Louisiana / Hampton
8) Creighton
8) Rhode Island
9) Oklahoma 9) NC State
Boise – March 15/17 Boise – March 15/17
5) Florida
5) Clemson
12) Middle Tennessee 12) Loyola (IL)
4) Wichita St. 4) West Virginia
13) Vermont 13) Buffalo
Dallas – March 15/17 Detroit – March 16/18
6) Miami (FL) 6) Kentucky
11) Alabama / Saint Mary’s 11) Baylor / Marquette
3) Michigan St. 3) Cincinnati
14) Montana 14) UNC Greensboro
Nashville – March 16/18 Pittsburgh – March 15/17
7) TCU 7) Seton Hall
10) Florida St. 10) Kansas St.
2) Auburn 2) North Carolina
15) UC Davis
15) Penn
WEST (LOS ANGELES)   MIDWEST (OMAHA)
Wichita – March 15/17 Nashville – March 16/18
1) Kansas 1) Xavier
16) Iona 16) Radford
8) Nevada 8) Virginia Tech
9) Butler 9) St. Bonaventure
San Diego – March 16/18 San Diego – March 16/18
5) Gonzaga 5) Ohio St.
12) New Mexico St. 12) Murray St.
4) Arizona 4) Texas Tech
13) South Dakota St. 13) Louisiana
Wichita – March 15/17 Dallas – March 15/17
6) Texas A&M 6) Houston
11) Arizona St.
11) UCLA
3) Michigan 3) Tennessee
14) Bucknell 14) Charleston
Charlotte – March 16/18 Detroit – March 16/18
7) Arkansas 7) Missouri
10) Providence 10) Texas
2) Duke 2) Purdue
15) Lipscomb 15) Wright St.

Last Four In:

Alabama – The Tide seem determined to test the theory that the committee doesn’t give extra weight to the most recent games, as they have now lost five straight. On the positive side, they have three Top 20 RPI wins and five quadrant 1 victories, but the 14 in the loss column is concerning to say the least. Alabama is also just 2-8 in true road games, which means their SEC tournament opener against Texas A&M is essentially a must-win.

Saint Mary’s – It’s going to be a stressful few days for the Gaels after falling to BYU in the WCC semifinals. While predictive metrics like KenPom and BPI really like Saint Mary’s, there isn’t much meat on the actual resume. The Gaels have a huge road win at Gonzaga, a home victory over New Mexico State, and a regular season sweep of BYU, but 24 of their 28 victories came against quadrants 3 and 4. They accomplished very little in the non-conference while picking up losses to Georgia and Washington State, and a Saint Mary’s team with a relatively similar profile was left out just a couple years ago. A 10-1 mark in true road games helps the cause, but they are definitely a team I will be analyzing more closely over the remainder of the week.

Baylor – The Bears boast four quadrant 1 wins and have just one loss to a team not in the at-large picture. A 2-9 mark in true road games doesn’t help, but they did win a pair of neutral court games over Creighton and Wisconsin back in November. The predictive metrics like the Bears as well, but they need to find a way to knock off West Virginia in the Big 12 quarterfinals.

Marquette – After nearly being knocked off by DePaul late on Wednesday night, the Golden Eagles are still clinging to the final at-large spot, thanks in large part to a 5-5 mark in true road games and a winning record in total road and neutral games. The Golden Eagles also have four quadrant 1 wins, although none of those have come against a team in the RPI Top 25. Four more victories in quadrant 2 help their case, but a loss at DePaul is a clear blemish on their profile. Marquette gets a third crack at Villanova in the Big East Quarterfinals on Thursday.

First Five Out:

Oklahoma State – I’m not sure how possible it is for the Big 12 to get nine teams in the Big Dance, but the Cowboys knocked off Oklahoma on Wednesday and boast five quadrant 1 wins (including a sweep of Kansas) with no losses to teams outside of the Top 65 of the RPI. The main issues are a RPI in the mid-80s and a non-conference strength of schedule hovering in the 280s. Still, if the Cowboys can beat Kansas for a third time in the Big 12 Quarters, Oklahoma State can certainly make things interesting as we head toward Selection Sunday.

Louisville – The Cardinals played well in Wednesday’s win over Florida State, setting up a rematch with Virginia. The good news is that they don’t have a bad loss, but they also have zero wins against the RPI Top 50. The predictive metrics love Louisville, and four of their five best wins have come in road or neutral games. Still, the Cardinals face an uphill battle if they can’t find a way to knock off Virginia on Thursday.

USC – Despite finishing second in the Pac-12, I can’t ignore the fact that USC has yet to beat a team that’s an at-large lock with wins over Middle Tennessee State and New Mexico State their two best. Throw in the Bennie Boatright injury, and it just feels too easy and maybe too logical to leave USC out. Their two worst losses aren’t quite as bad as they look, as the SMU defeat came with the Mustangs at full strength and the home loss to Princeton coming in a game that multiple rotation players missed. Still, the lack of quality wins seems likely to hold them back.

Notre Dame – The Irish rallied from a 21-point deficit to knock off Virginia Tech and keep their at-large hopes alive. As I mentioned yesterday, Notre Dame suffered two of its worst losses while at full strength, and they now have just two wins over at-large caliber teams with everyone healthy. Still, with other bubble teams struggling, a win against Duke on Thursday would make their case more compelling.

Syracuse – The Orange made a second half run at North Carolina but eventually lost by nearly 20 points in the ACC tournament. Last Saturday’s home win over Clemson was a huge one for their at-large case, while road wins at Miami and Louisville also fall in quadrant 1. Bad losses at Georgia Tech and Wake Forest are the biggest issues, and it’s worth noting that 14 of Syracuse’s 20 wins fall in quadrants 3 and 4.

Conference Breakdown:

ACC (8): Clemson, Duke, Florida State, Miami (FL), North Carolina, North Carolina State, Virginia, Virginia Tech

Big 12 (8): Baylor, Kansas, Kansas State, Oklahoma, TCU, Texas, Texas Tech, West Virginia

SEC (8): Alabama, Arkansas, Auburn, Florida, Kentucky, Missouri, Tennessee, Texas A&M

Big East (7): Butler, Creighton, Marquette, Providence, Seton Hall, Villanova, Xavier

Big Ten (4): Michigan*, Michigan State, Ohio State, Purdue

American (3): Cincinnati, Houston, Wichita State

Pac-12 (3): Arizona, Arizona State, UCLA

Atlantic 10 (2): Rhode Island, St. Bonaventure

West Coast (2): Gonzaga*, Saint Mary’s

America East: Vermont

Atlantic Sun: Lipscomb*

Big Sky: Montana

Big South: Radford*

Big West: UC Davis

Colonial: Charleston*

Conference USA: Middle Tennessee

Horizon: Wright State*

Ivy: Penn

MAAC: Iona*

MAC: Buffalo

MEAC: Hampton

Missouri Valley: Loyola (IL)*

Mountain West: Nevada

Northeast: LIU Brooklyn*

Ohio Valley: Murray State*

Patriot: Bucknell*

Southern: UNC Greensboro*

Southland: SE Louisiana

SWAC: AR-Pine Bluff

Summit: South Dakota State*

Sun Belt: Louisiana

WAC: New Mexico State

* – Automatic Bid

Filed to:

  • Sandra Wilson

    Regardless of Duke’s seed, I think everyone knows they will play in North Carolina. It’s hard to imagine Kentucky not playing in Nashville. I know the B1G was horrible this year, but it’s hard to figure Nebraska out and Oklahoma in. OKLA. was next to last in their conference and were 8-10. Just about the same thing can be said about Texas and Baylor except that they haven’t completely fallen apart at the end like OKLA. There seems to be a huge need to adjust their tourney evaluation process. The quadrants should just be PART of the whole system.

  • Hoosiernation1887

    A handful of bubble teams lost yesterday, maybe with some more luck Nebraska still has a shot. I don’t think losing to Michigan should be as damaging to their resume as it seems to have been. Michigan proved they are for real, and also Nebraska already beat them this year.

  • Ivan Renko

    i agree, OK has absolutely no business in the tourney. they looked horrible limping to a 2-8 record over their past 10 games…including a 6 game losing streak.

    Big 12 and SEC way overrated.

  • sd chuck

    Agree, sooner or later, the losses have to take over and over ride the quadrants! I believe Penn St is a better team than OK! Nebraska should be in.

  • coachv

    in trying to take all subjectivity out of the selection process, the ncaa is throwing common sense out the window. a team circling the drain like oklahoma should not take away a spot from a team playing its best basketball at the end of the season. i think a little applied reason at the bottom of the bracket is ok

  • Donnie Vick

    Will the committee seriously give Louisville a bid? I can’t believe they would, especially if they are on the bubble.

  • vicbert caladipo

    Can we just start the tourney already so I can watch all the teams that don’t deserve to be in get bounced in the first week…………Roll call…Alabama, Louisville, Oklahoma, Baylor, texas, miss st, mizzu,florida st, ND, sec/acc/big12 etc etc. I’ve said it a dozen times and I need to stop but one last shout…..NOT GIVING ANY CREEDENCE TO HOT TEAMS IN THEIR LAST 10 AND NOT PUNISHING TEAMS GOING 2-8 IN THEIR LAST TEN IS BEYOND STUPID

  • vicbert caladipo

    If you haven’t beaten Duke, NC, VA,PU, MSU, OSU, Villanova, Xavier, Cincy,Kansas, Auburn or Gonzaga and you have a losing conference record or have 14plus losses you don’t deserve a shot. I’d rather see these mid major cinderellas get a shot than a team that has showed no consistency of winning…isn’t that what the tourney is all about…a team that can consistently win 6 games?

  • Colt

    I am doing something that I NEVER do tonight. I am rooting for Duke. I am so sick of all the “but Bonzi was hurt” bullcrap coming about ND.

  • David

    They need to stop with the a win at the beginning is the same as a win at the end crap. If that’s true give an automatic bid to the winner of the Mauii Invitational every year. After all if a win is a win, than a tournament championship is a tournament championship.

  • IdahoHoosier

    Yeah “good wins” early in the season just flat out shouldn’t have the same weight as “good wins” late in the season. Why are we rewarding teams who peaked in mid-December and punishing teams who got it together at the right time ending strong? It only hurts the NCAA tournament product.

  • IU Hoosiers # 34, 1979-83

    Vicbert!!! I’m done with taking the time to type my disgust in the selection process,,,,,,Ok i am done now! Did you shoot them straight last Tuesday while golfing?