About // Advertise // Archives // Contact
RSS Facebook Twitter

Tough injury for Hoosiers is tougher for Creek

by in Commentary | January 17th, 2011

(Photo credit: Jamie Owens)

Maurice Creek is injured again.

They are the words nobody remotely interested in Indiana basketball and its success wanted to hear ever, and certainly not this season.

Indeed, it was a moment of slight irony that this stress fracture, to Creek’s right patella (kneecap), came in close to the same way, in the same place, as they full fracture to his left patella last season, coming down awkwardly after a layup. And so, here we are again, circling around a major injury announcement involving a player that, as much as any, has become the face of Indiana.

It’s hard, unlike the last time, to feel like this development is even as bad for Indiana as it is for Creek.

Look, there’s the obvious argument that Creek wasn’t so pivotal a player this year as last, primarily because he’s not scoring so much as he was (which he’s not).

Creek is averaging 8.3 points per game — just one-tenth of a percentage point more than half of his scoring average through 12 games last season — on 38.9 percent shooting. In six more games this season to date, he’s attempted as many field goals (131) this year as he did over those 12 games last season. And he’s been in and out of the starting lineup recently.

In fairness to Creek, he still helps Indiana in ways others could not, particularly with ball handling, and Crean said the news of his injury was saddening, because the coach thought his sophomore shooting guard might soon turn a corner offensively.

“It just felt like it was really, really close to breaking for him,” Crean said at his radio show Monday night, according to Herald-Times beat writer Dustin Dopirak, who live-tweeted from the event.

But it’s hard to see how it hurts anyone more than it hurts Creek himself.

Here was a player Indiana has not had in some time. Creek had swagger.

Not the kind that drives one to spend an inordinate amount of time in front of a mirror, or convinces a person he or she is just generally incredible.

This was a better brand, a finer vintage if you will. Coaches will rave about a player’s “will to win” or “competitive fire.” They’re generally the same thing — an overall attitude that permeates every action, every moment spent chasing as much success as one can possibly get their hands on.

Creek didn’t care who he faced or what the odds, he had a fire that was only stoked by winning. It’s rare to find someone as skilled and as driven as Creek, and it was easy to envision three or four years of Creek as the posterchild of Indiana basketball.

Now, that’s all up in the air. Creek lost more than half a season to an injury he had yet to have been fully recovered from. Crean alluded to the moments where we’ve seen the old Maurice Creek, slashing across the lane, driving with confidence and, once or twice, finding his once-deadly 3-point shot.

All evidence suggested Creek worked hard in his rehabilitation too, pushing himself as much as he could to get back with as much swiftness and strength as possible. Returns this year have been mixed, but it’s generally acknowledged that his was a catastrophic injury, one that would need perhaps more than one year to heal.

The problem is, things aren’t nearly so cut-and-dry now.

Creek is out “indefinitely,” which is hard to quantify with 13 games plus the Big Ten Tournament and perhaps postseason play left on the schedule. It’s in his other knee, which could either be a good thing (no re-aggravation) or symptomatic of a larger problem.

It also leaves Creek in the unenviable position of having to face yet another frustrating period of rest and mending, one whose duration is apparently murky at best.

But there’s also a greater issue at stake here. Twelve months ago, Indiana basketball, as much as it could have been at the time, was settled. Even with Creek’s injury, there was plenty of time for him to rehabilitate, recover and reassert himself as the clear front man for a team and a program as it moved into the next phase of Tom Crean’s rebuilding process. As this season played out, and it became clear Creek’s renaissance would not be so smooth, doubt became cast on that aforementioned scenario.

This injury defeats it altogether.

There’s no blueprint moving forward from now. Is Maurice Creek ever going to be the high-scoring, program-turning player he once resembled? There’s no way to know. Are these injuries independent, or linked by some sort of greater physical issue? That’s something only an orthopedist, and more importantly time, can answer.

But time is the one thing Creek does not have. If this injury requires an extended layoff and rehabilitation, then he will have exhausted two years of eligibility for 30 total games. When he comes back, he will for a second time have to ingratiate himself with a team that has had to, by necessity, learn to live without him.

Next year, Cody Zeller comes to Indiana. The year after that, he’ll be joined by a bevy of heralded recruits, a list that’s long and could possibly get longer.

Indiana will be entering a new generation, one many believe will eventually vault the program back to its former glory.

As rough as this season has been for him, it was still fairly easy to see Creek in that future.

Now, no one can be sure.

  • http://twitter.com/realmatthoward Matt Howard

    this makes me want to throw up. not really a program killer but a tough, tough blow to a great kid. he’s as strong as it comes mentally, so i have no question that he’ll be back. Go Mo Go!

  • Jack in Seattle

    I’m so sorry for Mo. He deserves better luck. Wishing him all the best…

  • Aceman_Mujezinovic_07

    Well, that sucks!

    It really makes me wonder if there’s some underlying reason as to why he’s starting to suffer these injuries now when he hadn’t dealt with them to this point in his career. I coached a baseball player who kept having back problems until we finally encouraged him to get it checked out. Turned out that he had a genetic condition that caused repeated fractures and stress fractures in his vertebrae. I hope that Mo doesn’t have something that’s causing these injuries. Hopefully it’s just a simple case where his right leg was more susceptible because he was limping and putting extra stress on it. Maybe this is a blessing in disguise that now he’s going to get to sit and recover fully from his first injury and this stress fracture will heal much faster?

    Who knows but this sucks!!!

  • http://weeklycritiquely.blogspot.com/ IUfanPurduePhD

    sssssssssssuuuuuuuuuuuuuccccccccckkkkkkkkk.

  • http://weeklycritiquely.blogspot.com/ IUfanPurduePhD

    sssssssssssuuuuuuuuuuuuuccccccccckkkkkkkkk.

  • Anonymous

    Am I right in that the original injury was listed simply as a patella “fracture,” and not a “stress fracture”? It sucks either way for the kid, who absolutely busted his tail to get back for the season, but if the first one was a full fracture, hopefully the recovery for the new injury won’t be as long as the first one. If it is, I’d bet he re-evaluates the possibility of redshirting next year to have his next appearance on the floor at full strength. Hope it goes well for him, whichever way he goes.

  • MillaRed

    Stuff like this puts IU’s needs on a back burner. Mo’s basketball career may be in jeopardy. I have a little medical background myself and IMO this is not a result of the other injury. There are many other injuries that could have been a result of him favoring this or that. But fracturing both knee caps? Sorry but this sounds like an issue of bone strength in this area of the body. Especially when you examine the nature of the injury. Going to the hole before you even elevate?

    Obviously the coaching staff and even ITH was in favor of Mo playing this year but I was not. (I am sure Mo would not agree). Furthermore, I think he should sit 2011 out and just plain let it all heal as much as possible and ensure he is absolutely 100% before he hits the floor. We were going to struggle this year anyway. If he goes into a season completely healthy, he can have the mental mindset that he can go as hard as he can and if something happens again it just wasn’t meant to be.

    A healthy Mo will fit into any class of any lineup in any season IU has to offer. I really hope the best for him because this news just makes me sick to my stomach. Real sorry to hear it Mo.

  • Diesel

    The negatives are obvious.

    Here are the positives:
    + No where near the injury of last season. No surgery, no screws, no immobilizer, no year long rehab. I foresee 4-6 weeks of down time and the recovery should be simple.
    + This is no where near the loss to this team as it was to last years team.
    + Mo can begin to focus on rehabilitating his injury from last season to full. While he is at it, a psychologist would be smart
    + This team played well for several games after the loss of Mo last season
    + The development of VO and WS just stepped up a notch

  • Anonymous

    Well written post on a tough subject. I especially liked the part about Creek’s swagger – he really carried himself in a way that few players do (quick comparison – AJ Moye maybe?). Nice work Zach.

    And again, my heart goes out to Creek, as I said in the other post.

  • Anonymous

    Man I hate to rain on your silver lining parade, but are we sure about the no surgery thing? Feels like we really don’t know yet what he’s going to need to recover. I’m hoping you’re right though

  • Anonymous

    Since it’s already been brought up by others, I agree that this injury doesn’t seem related to the last one, at least not in the sense of him overcompensating. It’s a fractured kneecap. I just can’t imagine how you do that by overcompensating, especially on a play that was inherently awkward. The only connection I can imagine is having bad kneecaps to begin with, some sort of preexisting defect as Aceman hypothesized above.

  • Anonymous

    A couple of Tweets from our Hoosiers:
    VICICANFLY4IU Victor Oladipo
    i love my big brother @Maurice_Creek3

    Maurice_Creek3
    @VICICANFLY4IU….love you 2 Lil bro…this is your time to shine DMV style..ill be back its just gonna be awhile….

  • WestCoast Hoosier

    Classic example of when bad things happen to nice people.

    In this case, obviously a really nice guy and potentially a great player. So sorry.

    Thinking about it though, his legs have always looked less “robust” than the rest of him, which leads one to worry about some intrinsic condition.In the law, there is the concept of the “eggshell plaintiff,” which refers to someone who has a condition that makes normal bumps into serious injuries e.g. You bump a kid in a normal game of tag on a playground and their leg collapses. Mo may fit that bill on some level, although we all hope not.

    Interestingly, Robbie Hummel may have a similar situation.

    The good news is that Mo does not seem to be a kid without other skills, and I mean life skills. Basketball is a game that can, in rare cases, allow someone to make a living, and, in very rare cases, allow someone true fame and fortune.

    But, despite the hype, most college ballplayers are not going to make it to the pros and most of those who make it, aren’t going to stay for 15 years. For every Eric Gordon, there are many Kirk Hastons.

    But a good education can allow someone to have a good life as a professional — in some other area. And if Mo Creek never plays pro ball, I get the feeling that he’ll make it in the most important game – the game of life. He doesn’t seem to be one of those kids who had better make it as an athlete because that is the only hope.

    I wish him that good life, first and foremost. And beyond that, I hope that he does get back and that he does make it to the pros and stars and all that stuff.

    But if that doesn’t happen, he still has the first part to fall back on.

  • IU_Fan_99

    brought a tear to my eye….

  • Anonymous

    So sad for Mo! Everything I’ve heard about him leads me to believe that he is a hard-working, driven, and dedicated player. Not that I’d ever wish injury on anyone, but it’s even more heartbreaking when it happens to such a great kid who’s worked so hard to get back to where he was.

    I have no doubt after seeing his determination in coming back this year that Mo will work hard, I just hope he’s able to get it back both physically and mentally. Wishing him nothing but the best in his recovery!

  • Anonymous

    So very sad for him, will add him to the prayer list.

    I somewhat reminded of Pat Graham, who was never the same after his repeated foot injuries.

  • Anonymous

    I would not be a bit surprised if the extra stress he was placing on the knee from limping contributed to this injury. I have also noticed that his calves do not seem to be very muscular compared to his upper legs. I wonder if this might be a factor? I think he should bag this season and just do strengthening exercises and shooting until he is fully healed. No more running or playing while limping.

    Because this is a stress Fx he should be able to recover much quicker. I sustained a stress Fx in my foot from running long distances but with six weeks rest and gradual training I was fine to compete again in a few months.

  • Anonymous

    This is a stress fracture. These types of injuries come when too much stress is placed on a bone or joint usually over a period of time. Because he was favoring his original injury the other knee was being subjected to much more weight and stress than it would be accustomed to. This happens to athletes sometimes when they injure one side of the body and try to keep competing. The other side sometimes becomes aggravated from too much stress. It has happened to me and some of my friends. It is possible that he does have a physical or genetic predisposition. However he never displayed this tendency before the original injury at IU that I am aware of.

  • Kelin Blab

    If I am thinking long term for Mo, I would not put him back on the court until he is 100% with both his knees and the leg and knee strength exceeds previous levels. The kid already has really skinny legs, I just would not put him out there again until he has his full mobility and confidence in his legs.

  • Anonymous

    I feel bad for Mo as well but I think the key here is that it is the other knee. Stress fractures generally just require a little rest and I don’t think that would be a bad thing for his other knee right now too. He seems to limp quite a bit whether that’s a mental thing at this point who knows. The poor kid has been busting his butt out there trying to help the team so I hope he can use this time to recover mentally and physically and look ahead to a brighter future for himself and the program.

  • JerryCT

    I fully agree with you. Nothing wrong w a red shirt year to make sure this kid has the best chance to play at the level of his dreams.

    I think the problem is knowing when he has reached 100%. An xray may show that bone has healed but the remaining muscle/ligament imbalances set him up for another injury of almost any kind.

    I , like Millared and others , thought that his limping around the floor was a clear indicator that he should not be playing. I hope this indicator is used next time to determine his comeback.

    Furthermore, his game is such that he lets the game come to him and thus he fits in with any kind of team we put on the floor in the future.

  • JerryCT

    Yup, and also reminds me of perhaps the best college scorer to play in the state , Austin Carr at ND …………… same bad deal.

  • Luke72

    This is one of those when someone refers to the old “everything happens for a reason” you’re left
    wondering why! Creek is the type of kid that any program in the country would love to have. Not just for his previous stats but for his positive attitude and the joy you can see when he plays the game!
    Doubt that you are reading this Mo, but if you are,
    any true fan admires the spirit you’ve shown and believes that however this works out we are proud to have you as part of the IU family!!

  • Diesel

    If it is as IU says at this point, no surgery would be needed, just rest for the bone to heal which is generally 4-6 weeks.

  • Diesel

    Well put trailrunner. What we saw was just the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back folks. I would agree that the overcompensation played a part, but I do not fault IU or the medical staff or anyone else. Everyone knew the risks involved.

  • Diesel

    Jerry, there are tests that can be used to get a really good measure of Mo’s leg strength and functional ability. We can only make the assumption that IU is using everything available to them, but you’re right in we never heard anything that said his leg strength was 85% or anything like that.

  • Dannon Brown

    absolutely devastating for this kid. I can honestly say i dont have a single concern with where Indiana stands after losing Mo. I am 100% concerned with this great kid who again has to face this unfortunate adversity. You are in my prayers Mo

  • Anonymous

    Ok cool, I hadn’t heard that yet. Hope it turns out to be accurate.

  • Anonymous

    I stand very much corrected. I figured since it appeared to happen on that specific play, rather than over the course of time, it wasn’t related to overcompensating. I also intended on putting one of those “I’m not doctor, but…”‘s in my original post so that a real doctor (or med student or whatever) could come and correct me. Seriously though, thanks TR for putting me in my uninformed place.

  • Anonymous

    If for some reason Mo is unable to return to his prior self it is important to always remember the drive that this kid had and the glimpses of absolute brilliance that he had shown. So unfortunate to have this happen again and I my heart goes out to him. I’m sure Mo is not reading these posts but if so, Mo we will all remember you and we are proud to have had a young man like you wear the candy striped pants and represent this proud program the way you did. There is no doubt that with the drive, character, and passion that you possess that you will someday be truly successful….again my heart goes out to you….hope to see you back and scoring 31 against Kentucky!!!

  • Plane1972

    I hope a guy like DJ White could reach out to Mo and let him know there is light at the end of the tunnel of back-to-back injuries like this if he can sustain a positive attitude and work through it like he did the first time.

    All the best, Mo. We know you will overcome this.

  • JerryCT

    Diesel , you know more than me as a PT guy. I can however take it from the patient angle having had microfracture and high tibial osteotemy ie tissues and bone. I believe that ROM and certain strength tests are good but not a sufficient indicator of :

    + whether you can functionally play your sport at a high level
    + how much stamina the muscles and tissues can endure before imbalance takes over

    I always felt the limping was obvious and the imbalance perilous . He was always on the verge of a tumble or an awkward move.

    I know they all thought they were doing the right thing but GGGEEEZZZ !

  • JerryCT

    GYM – I am gong with your attitude but I still think even a hint of a limp means there is an imbalance , physical or mental it matters not, the imbalance imperils his ability to play at a high level w/o another injury of any kind .

  • Anonymous

    On another note, let this be a rallying point for the other young men on this team. You have to go out and give it everything you have every single time you step onto the court because you never know when it is all going to be taken away from you. If motivation was something this team was looking for well then now they have it. They are now down one of their best players (even if he hadn’t been his prior self this year) and the odds are even more against them, just like they are against Mo. Go out and show Mo that none of you are taking this opportunity for granted and that you all want to rebuild the storied tradition of this power house collegiate basketball team. Go Hoosiers, do it for you, us, and now Mo!!!

  • Marquisimo

    Is a medical redshirt a possibility for this guy to get him a 5th year at Indiana…

  • stonaroni

    Sorry to hear this about Mo. You know he wants to be better than he has played this year and he wants to be 100%.

    I really think IU needs to consider a medical redshirt for next season so when he comes back in 2012-13 as a 4th year JR he is 100%. I say this because I feel WS and VO can gives us more than a 75% Mo Creek.

    Also, though many do not give him love, Austin Etherington can fill the role that Mo has had on this team in 2010-11 when he arrives next year.

    When 2012-13 rolls around, someone will have to sit. CW plays the #3 along with, VO, WS, AE, Mo. But, that is a great problem to have meaning we have depth and tons of talent.

    And, there is no guarantee that someone else doesn’t blow out a knee or break an ankle who will have to sit when Mo comes off red-shirting.

    Scholarship wise.it should work out since GMM will be off his scholly next year.

    I will not be shocked if we see another leave at the end of the season freeing up another 2011 or 2012 recruit.

    There are better days ahead and a less than 100% Mo Creek nexy season just takes time away from players who are very skilled, hardworking players.

  • Diesel

    Impressive surgery (and recovery as you know) Jerry. You can appreciate that there is some grey area between being well enough to be active and participate in athletic activities, and being 100%. There are some things like isokinetic strength testing, functional movement screens, and functional progressions that can help in determining one’s ability to particpate effectively and safely.

    Mo as we all could tell was never 100% from the previous knee injury, and strength and endurance as you mention would be the key.

    We always have to remember as well that injury is inherent to sport and sometimes we can chalk it up to bad luck.

  • JerryCT

    Good and appropriate idea there

  • MillaRed

    Frankly we all are speculating. What we do know is this happened the exact same way on the floor and both are injured kneecaps and sorry but that is just a really strange coincidence.

    Stress fractures occur in a 100 different ways.

  • MillaRed

    I’m beginning to wonder if he was even 85%. At times that leg was so stiff he was just awkward looking.

    I’m not giving Crean any heat for this at all. You have to trust the player too when it comes to how he feels out there. But I was never was in favor of the “he needs to play through this” philosophy. We were not going to be a great team anyway

    It will be interesting to see how others in the media perceive this situation.

  • MillaRed

    Indeed, regardless of the recovery Mo’s battle is 100% mental now. As I mentioned earlier, it’s easier said than done but get those legs as strong AND flexible as possible and just go nuts. You can’t play scared. If you are fully confident physically you have to go all out and just let the chips fall where they may.

    If he injures a kneecap again, you have to look in the mirror and realize something is going on that is out of your control and focus on the other things needed to be successful. We only get one shot at life and 99.99999% of us do it without playing high level basketball.

    P.S. Drink a half gallon of milk a day Mo!

  • Anonymous

    he isn’t dead, and hopefully he can be back to his old game in the future. your post just seems a little cryptic, not trying to be offensive

  • Anonymous

    I have thought the same thing, and this is going to sound as if I’m trivializing the situation, but I’m not–I’m just looking at what I think his frame of mind may have been in coming back from the initial injury: IU does not need him back next year. Before you jump me, hear me out…Mo was obviously the best player on the team until he was hurt the first time, and there’s no doubt, if healthy, he’d be the best player on the team right now. That being said, I assume his competitive nature led him to get back as soon as possible because he wanted to do what was best for the team. The current roster is deepest at wing/2 guard (his position,) and will continue to be so next year with Victor, Will, Austin, and Verdell (when not at the point.) Mo should do what is best for himself, but at this point being less than 100% puts him at the position of “just another player,” with the depth there, so there’s no reason to rush back and risk further damage if he isn’t able to compete to the level of his capability.

  • Anonymous

    And in the case of both of these injuries, there was no contact.

    If he does redshirt, good for him–that’s just another year of classes to soak in.

    Oh, and by the way…if there are “many Kirk Hastons” why the hell don’t we have any on the roster!?

  • Anonymous

    If I remember correctly, the cutoff for opportunity to apply for medical redshirt is 10% of your team’s games. Last year’s injury was a few games past that, and this season it’s even further beyond it, so I’d say no.

  • N71

    Sits this year and all next, comes back senior year, blows the doors off and goes pro, late first round. Makes millions and comes back to Bloomington after his career in the NBA to raise his family, spend time around the program, and do whatever he wants for a living because he has a degree from Indiana. Mo will be fine. Just needs to pace himself.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe could have used better words for the post. Not trying to write a eulogy, just simply saying that no matter what the future holds for Creek with IU basketball that his efforts and character would not be forgotten. I am very hopeful that he does come back to full strength, but after the hard time he had this year getting back coupled with the unlikely extra year of eligibility let’s face it…we don’t know.

  • Bleeding Crimson

    Like the idea as others have said as well. This will almost insure 100% recovery not only for his body and strength but his mind-set as well. We will be deep at almost every position come 2012 and with his leader-ship will also insure success. Here is to a full recovery. We love you Creek.

  • cooper

    The only smart option is to keep him out for this year and next. He was rushed back this year when anyone could see he moved like a cripple. Most of us commented on it during the chats. If I were his parents I’d have some serious questions for the medical staff and how they handled him coming back. It wouldn’t shock me if he transfers

    He needed more time and in compensating he damaged the other knee. If he comes back next year it won’t be at full strength. So red shirt him and give him time to get as healthy as possible.

  • Diesel

    Anyone needing health advice should submit a question to the next live chat this Thursday at 11:30 AM over at the Hoosier Scoop

ITH on Twitter

Resources

Recruiting

Comments